Monday: a sales rep at a steel carport manufacturer sends a quote for PLN 100,000 net, valid for 14 days. Steel accounts for 45% of the price, the margin is 18%. The customer stays silent for almost two weeks and on Friday, the thirteenth day, replies: “We accept, please give us a date.” Sheet metal and sections are only purchased once the deposit is paid, which is another ten days away. In the meantime, the steel wholesaler has raised its prices twice. The quote is accepted, the price is binding, and the profit on this order has just shrunk. Nobody in the company will notice before the quarter is closed.
This article is for manufacturers who sell products made of steel, aluminium or any other raw material with a volatile price: steel structures, gates and fencing, racking, fitted interiors, aluminium joinery, made-to-order machinery. We show how much margin quote validity costs, what the law says (less than you might think), how to write a price adjustment (indexation) clause that actually works, and what a configurator or quoting systemcan do about it, so that sales reps do not have to keep track of steel mill prices.
Quote validity is not 14 days, but 14 days plus the time until you buy the material
Most companies look at price risk through the lens of quote validity. That is only half the picture. The risk lasts from the day you calculate the price to the day you buy the material. If you order material after the deposit, after drawings are approved or in a weekly batch, another week or two is added to the 14 days of validity. So the risk window in the carport example is 23 days, not 14.
How much this costs depends on two numbers: the material's share of the selling price and how much it goes up within that window. With an 18% margin, it looks like this:
| Material share of price | Material up 5% | up 10% | up 20% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 30% (e.g. labour-intensive products) | 16,5% | 15,0% | 12,0% |
| 45% (e.g. carports, gates, racking) | 15,8% | 13,5% | 9,0% |
| 60% (e.g. steel structures, sections, sheet metal cut to size) | 15,0% | 12,0% | 6,0% |
A 20% rise within a few weeks sounds like a worst-case scenario, but the steel market has already seen it. According to Fastmarkets, hot-rolled coil (HRC) in Northern Europe cost EUR 961 per tonne on 18 February 2022. On 21 March, according to S&P Global, it was EUR 1,460 per tonne in the Ruhr. That is 52% in just over a month. Aluminium on the LME broke through USD 3,900 per tonne in the first week of March 2022 and fell by several hundred dollars a day later. Prices can also fall, and that is the second reason why the clause must work both ways.
What the law says: four things worth knowing
This is not legal advice, but a map that makes it easier to talk to a lawyer. Four provisions explain why “it will all work out somehow” does not work.
1. A quote with a deadline is binding until the deadline expires. The Polish Civil Code (Article 66) states that an offer specifying a deadline for a response binds the offeror until that deadline expires. If the customer accepts it on the thirteenth day, the contract is concluded at the old price. A note saying “prices are subject to change” without clear rules will not help, because nobody knows when or by how much.
2. A lump-sum price stays a lump sum. When you make a product to order to the customer's dimensions, the contract is often a contract for specific work or a construction works contract. For lump-sum remuneration, Article 632 of the Polish Civil Code is explicit: the contractor cannot demand an increase, even if the scope or cost of the work could not be foreseen when the contract was concluded. A court may increase the lump sum only if performance would expose the contractor to a gross loss due to an unforeseeable change. In its judgment of 24 May 2019 (I CSK 218/18), the Supreme Court held that a professional should take into account changes in material prices during the term of a contract. It is better not to count on the courts to protect your margin.
3. With consumers, a price increase only comes with a right of withdrawal. If you also sell to private individuals, for example gates, fencing or fitted interiors via an online configurator, Article 385³ point 20 of the Polish Civil Code treats as unfair, in case of doubt, a provision that allows the price to be increased after the contract is concluded without giving the consumer the right to withdraw. You have two options: a fixed price with the risk on your side, or a clause that gives the customer the right to withdraw. The same protection covers some sole traders when they buy something that is not of a professional nature for them.
4. In public procurement, price adjustment is mandatory. Following the 2022 amendment, Article 439 of the Polish Public Procurement Law requires that a contract for works, supplies or services concluded for more than 6 months must set out the rules for changing the remuneration when material prices or costs change. The National Appeals Chamber (KIO) regularly deals with “sham” clauses, meaning clauses that formally exist but, because of a very high threshold or a low cap, practically cannot take effect. If you bid in tenders, it is worth reading the draft contract with this in mind before you submit your bid.
How to build a price adjustment clause that works
A good clause is boring: the customer reads it once, understands it and has nothing to argue about. It consists of six elements.
- An index from a public source. A quotation both parties can check: the aluminium price on the LME, HRC sheet prices, the industrial producer price index published by Statistics Poland (GUS), or the price list of a specific steel mill or distributor. Not “market prices” and not “our suppliers' prices”, because the customer cannot verify those.
- Material share of the price. You adjust only the material portion, not the whole price. The formula looks like this: new price = quoted price × (fixed portion + material portion × index today ÷ index on the quote date). With a 45% share, a 10% rise in steel adds 4.5% to the price, not 10%.
- Threshold. You absorb small fluctuations yourself, for example up to a 3% or 5% change in the index. The customer gets a stable price, and you do not have to correct invoices by a few dozen zlotys. However, the threshold must not be so high that the clause never kicks in.
- Two dates. The base value date (the quote date) and the comparison date (the day the material is ordered or the day the quote is accepted). Without them, each party will pick the day that suits it.
- Symmetry. The price goes up and down. A clause that works only in the manufacturer's favour is harder to defend, and B2B customers increasingly ask for this themselves, because they remember steel prices falling after 2022.
- Procedure. Who calculates, within what time the customer is informed and what documents are shown. The simplest approach: before ordering the material, you send the customer the index values for both dates, with the source, and the new price.
This model is not an invention. For years, stainless steel producers have added a monthly alloy surcharge, linked to nickel, chromium and molybdenum prices, separately from the base price. Customers know it and accept it, because it is public, calculable and works both ways. It is a good template for anyone selling products made from a raw material with a volatile price.
Calculate how much you risk on your quote
Enter the value of a typical quote, your margin, the material share and how quickly you buy material after an order. The calculator will show how much margin the risk window costs, how much a clause with a threshold recovers, what quote validity is safe and what the wording in your quote could look like.
Calculator: how much margin quote validity eats up
We calculate the worst case: the customer accepts the quote on the last day, and you only buy the material after the order is accepted. The material price change is spread evenly over time.
Illustrative model, not legal advice. Agree the wording of the clause with a lawyer, especially in consumer contracts.
What a configurator or quoting system can do about it
A clause in the quote template is only half the job. The other half is keeping an eye on the numbers: what the index was on the quote date, what it is today, whether it has crossed the threshold and who needs to know. In Excel and Word, this relies on the sales rep's memory. In a configurator, rules do it. In the systems we build for manufacturers, six features prove their worth.
| Function | What it does | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Index stored in the quote | Every quote stores the index value and the material price list from the pricing date. | On acceptance, you know what to calculate the change from, without searching through emails. |
| Material-dependent validity | Items with a high share of steel or aluminium get a shorter validity period than those dominated by labour. | A quote for an installation service can be valid for 30 days, and one for a steel structure for 7. |
| Separate “material surcharge” line | The base price is fixed, and the surcharge is calculated from the index, like the alloy surcharge for stainless steel. | The customer sees what is fixed and what is variable, and does not argue about the whole price. |
| Recalculation on acceptance | When the customer accepts the quote, the system compares the index with the base value and checks the threshold. | Below the threshold, the order goes ahead; above it, the sales rep gets a ready calculation for the customer. |
| Threshold breach alert | After the index is updated, the system flags open quotes in which the change has exceeded the threshold. | The sales rep calls the customer before acceptance, not after. |
| Lost margin report | A comparison of the quoted margin with the margin after the actual material purchase. | Management sees how much quote validity costs and makes decisions based on numbers, not gut feeling. |
Where does the system get the index from? LME data is licensed and paid for, and sheet metal prices are published by industry services on a subscription basis. For most manufacturers, a simpler solution is enough: someone from purchasing enters the current index or distributor price list in the admin panel once a week, and the system does the rest. Automatic retrieval makes sense when the index is public, for example Statistics Poland (GUS) indicators, or when the wholesaler provides its price list as a file or via an API.
If you calculate prices from a dimension table, the index can be applied to the entire price list with a single factor. If you calculate the price with a formula based on kilograms of material, price adjustment is even more accurate, because the system knows the weight of steel in each item. We describe the difference between these approaches in our article on matrix pricing versus formula pricing in a configurator.
5 mistakes with price adjustment clauses
- “Prices are subject to change” instead of rules. Without an index, a threshold and dates, such a note protects nothing, and the customer is entitled to assume they accepted the quote at the stated price.
- Adjusting the whole price. The customer pays more for installation and design because steel has gone up. This is easy to challenge and hard to justify.
- A threshold so high it never applies. A clause with a 15% threshold and an 18% margin only protects against disaster, not against a typical price rise.
- No material purchase date. If you calculate the change up to the acceptance date but buy the material two weeks later, that part of the risk remains unprotected.
- The same clause for businesses and consumers. In a contract with a private individual, a clause without a right of withdrawal in the event of a price increase may turn out to be unfair.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a price adjustment clause in a quote?
It is a provision that specifies in advance how the price changes when the cost of a specified material changes. It includes an index from a public source, the material share of the price, the threshold above which the price changes, the comparison dates and the procedure for informing the customer. It allows you to offer a longer quote validity without the risk of losing margin.
Can I raise the price if the customer accepted the quote within the deadline?
As a rule, no. A quote with a deadline is binding until it expires, and acceptance within the deadline concludes the contract at the quoted price. A change is possible if the quote contained a clear price adjustment clause or if the customer agrees to the new price. Check the details with a lawyer, as they depend on the wording of the quote and the type of contract.
Which index should I choose for steel products?
The one that best reflects what you actually buy and that both parties can check. For sheet and coil, that means hot-rolled coil (HRC) prices; for sections and bars, long product prices or a specific distributor's price list. A more general measure is the industrial producer price index published by Statistics Poland (GUS).
Does a price adjustment clause work in a consumer contract?
It can, but it must give the consumer the right to withdraw from the contract if the price rises. The Polish Civil Code treats as unfair, in case of doubt, a provision that allows the price to be increased after the contract is concluded without such a right. The alternative is a fixed price and a shorter quote validity.
How long should a quote for steel products be valid?
It depends on the material share of the price, market volatility and the time from order to material purchase. The calculator in this article works out the maximum validity at which the margin falls by no more than 2 percentage points. With a 45% steel share, prices rising by 5% a month and material bought 10 days after the order, the result is 16 days. With a price adjustment clause, the validity can be longer.
Next step
If your sales reps calculate quotes in Excel and check material prices “by eye”, send us your price list, two or three typical quotes and information on where you get your steel or aluminium prices from. We will show you how to store the index, threshold and material surcharge in a configurator and quoting system, and how much work the first version requires. You can find working configurator examples in JSON Crew showroom.
Write to us or see what a configurator implementation looks like, from the first conversation to a working MVP.
Read also
- Matrix price list vs formula: how to price a roller blind, insect screen or venetian blind in a configurator
- Online fence quote: panels, posts, gate and pedestrian gate in a configurator
- Configurator, CPQ and supplier catalog in non-serial manufacturing
- What is CPQ (Configure, Price, Quote)
- How much does a configurator cost? Realistic ranges and what affects the price
