// Configurators

Order dimension vs production dimension: where “too small” and “too big” complaints come from

Zespół JSON Crew przy pracy, okładka artykułu o wymiarze z zamówienia i wymiarze produkcyjnym

A customer fills in the form: sliding wardrobe, width 2400 mm, height 2450 mm, floor to ceiling. The salesperson copies these numbers into the order, production cuts the boards, and the fitter arrives three weeks later. The wardrobe does not fit. The customer measured the recess at eye level, but the wall is out of true near the floor and the recess is only 2392 mm there. On top of that, a carcass 2400 mm high and 600 mm deep cannot be tilted upright in a room that is 2450 mm to the ceiling, because the carcass diagonal is longer than the room height. Nobody made a calculation error. Everyone understood “width” differently, because the order dimension and the production dimension are two different numbers.

This article is for manufacturers of made-to-measure products: windows and doors, roller shutters, fitted furniture, balustrades, gates, steel structures and sheet metal parts. We show how the order dimension differs from the production dimension, where clearances and allowances come from, how to measure so that you avoid “too small” and “too big” complaints, and what of this can be handled by a website configurator or a quoting system. At the end there is a calculator that converts the customer's dimension into the cutting dimension.

One dimension, four meanings

When people talk about a made-to-measure product, there are usually four different numbers in play, and all of them are called “width”. The opening size is what is in the masonry or between the walls. The order dimension is what the customer or salesperson wrote down. The production dimension is what goes to the saw, the press or the CNC machine. The clear opening of the finished product is what is left for passage, glazing or vehicle access. For one product the difference between them is a few millimetres, for another it is several tens of centimetres.

ProductWhat the customer usually givesWhat goes to productionWhere the difference comes from
Window in a masonry openingWidth and height of the openingFrame sizeThe frame is smaller than the opening by a fitting clearance on each side, usually ten to twenty millimetres
Interior Doors“80 door”Leaf, frame and wall openingFor an “80” door the leaf is about 84 cm and the wall opening about 90 cm. Three numbers under one name
External roller shutterOpening or window sizeWidth including guide rails, height including the boxDepends on the system: inside the opening, on the window frame or top-mounted
Built-in wardrobeWidth and height of the recessCarcasses and frontsWalls are rarely parallel, and the carcass still has to be stood upright in the room
Sliding gateDriveway widthLeaf lengthThe leaf is longer by the counterbalance, often by 40 to 50% of the clear driveway width
Folded sheet metal partExternal dimensions from the drawingDeveloped length, i.e. the flat blank to cutThe flat blank is shorter than the sum of the external dimensions and depends on sheet thickness and bend radius
Indicative values. Actual clearances and allowances depend on the manufacturer's system, material and technology.

The customer is not obliged to know these differences. The problem starts when the order form does not know them either: there is a single “width” field, and nobody records whether it means the opening or the product, or who measured it.

Where the difference comes from: five sources

1. Fitting clearance. The product has to fit into the opening, and there must be space between it and the wall for anchors, packers, foam and sealing tapes. Window installation guidelines, such as the German RAL guidelines, set the minimum gap according to the material and the frame length: the longer the frame and the more the material moves, the bigger the gap. Clearance is not a margin “just in case”, it is part of the technology.

2. Walls out of true. A wall opening is not the rectangle on the drawing. Deviations of a few millimetres per metre in walls and plaster are normal. That is why width is measured in three places (top, middle and bottom) and height on both sides and in the middle. Production uses the smallest result. A customer who measures once, at eye level, almost always gives a dimension larger than the narrowest point of the opening.

3. Thermal expansion. Frames, profiles and balustrades change length with temperature. Between winter and full sun, a light-coloured frame goes through a difference of around 50 degrees, a dark one as much as 70 to 80 degrees. For a three-metre element it looks like this:

MaterialExpansion coefficientChange in length of 3 m at 50 K
PVC (window profiles)about 0.07 to 0.08 mm/(m·K)about 11 to 12 mm
Aluminiumabout 0.024 mm/(m·K)about 3.6 mm
Steelabout 0.012 mm/(m·K)about 1.8 mm
Calculation: length in metres × coefficient × temperature difference. For wood and furniture board, moisture matters more than temperature.

The movement is split between both sides, but with a long, dark PVC frame the clearance on each side has to absorb several millimetres of material movement alone. The same clearance on a steel balustrade can be much smaller.

4. Technological allowances. The production dimension is often not the dimension of the finished product. PVC profiles are cut longer by an allowance that disappears in the weld. The saw takes a kerf, so one bar yields fewer pieces than simple division suggests. Sheet metal is cut to the developed length, not to the sum of the external dimensions. The process engineer knows these numbers, but the customer and the salesperson do not, and they should not have to.

5. Installation and transport. The product has to fit not only into the opening but also on the way to it. A wardrobe carcass 2400 mm high and 600 mm deep has a side diagonal of about 2474 mm. If the room is 2450 mm to the ceiling, you cannot tilt a carcass assembled lying down into an upright position. The same applies to door widths, stairwells and lifts for large glazing. Then there are manufacturing tolerances: under the general standard ISO 2768, medium class, a dimension from 1000 to 2000 mm may deviate from nominal by ±1.2 mm, and from 2000 to 4000 mm by ±2 mm.

Who measured and which dimension they gave: this must be in the order

Most dimension disputes are not about what the width is, but about whose number it was. If the order confirmation says “2400 × 2450” rather than “recess 2400 × 2450, customer's single-point measurement, production size 2380 × 2340”, then after a complaint each side has its own version. A good order for a made-to-measure product contains:

  • Dimension type. Opening, recess, product size or clear opening. Ideally with a drawing showing what was measured from where to where.
  • Who measured. The customer, the salesperson, the fitter or an outside company. This determines who is responsible if the dimension turns out to be wrong.
  • All measurements, not just one. Three widths and three heights tell production more than a single number, because they show whether the opening is out of true.
  • Production size kept separate. Calculated by rules and shown on the work order next to the sales dimension, not overwritten by hand in the same field.
  • Customer confirmation. The customer approves the finished product size, not just their own measurement. Then they know the wardrobe will be 2380 mm, not 2400.

Convert the customer's dimension into the production size

Choose the product type, enter the opening measurements and the clearances you use. The calculator takes the smallest measurement, subtracts the clearances, checks material movement and shows what would happen if production used only the middle measurement. At the bottom you get a ready dimension note for the work order.

Calculator: from opening measurement to production size

The clearances in the presets are examples. Enter the ones your technology uses. All dimensions in millimetres.

Measurement

Technology

Production size0
Governing opening0
Measurement spread0
Material movement0
    Dimension note for the work order

    What a configurator or quoting system can do about it

    With Excel and email, converting the customer's dimension into the production size lives in the head of a salesperson or process engineer. If that person is on holiday, the order goes to production with the number the customer typed in. In a configurator this knowledge is written into rules and works the same way for every order. In the systems we build for made-to-measure manufacturers, six features prove their worth.

    FunctionWhat it doesWhy
    Dimension field with type and drawingThe customer chooses whether they are giving the opening size or the product size, and next to it sees a drawing showing what to measure from where to where.No more “is that the clear opening?” question asked by the salesperson after the fact.
    Three measurements instead of oneThe form asks for the width at the top, middle and bottom and for three heights, and uses the smallest result for the quote.An out-of-true opening shows up at the order stage, not during installation.
    Clearance and allowance rulesClearances depend on product, system, material and colour. A dark PVC frame gets a different clearance than a light one, and a steel balustrade a different one than a window.The process engineer sets the rule once instead of correcting every order.
    Two dimensions on the work orderThe work order shows the sales dimension (from the order) and the production dimension (after rules), each in its own field.In case of a complaint you can see what the customer gave and what the system calculated.
    Technical limitsThe system enforces the maximum leaf width, weight, carcass diagonal or bar length, and blocks or splits the order.The salesperson does not sell something that production cannot make or the fitter cannot carry in.
    Cutting list and panel cut listFrom the production dimension the system calculates profile lengths with allowances, board cut parts or sheet metal flat blanks.Production receives a ready list, not a dimension to recalculate on its own.

    Price is a separate matter. Many companies calculate it from a matrix price list based on the order dimension, rounded up to the nearest grid step, but manufacture to the production dimension. That works well, provided both dimensions are stored separately and nobody prices from the production dimension just because it was to hand. We describe the difference between table prices and formula prices in our article on matrix pricing versus formula pricing in a configurator, and converting wardrobe dimensions into CNC cut parts in our article on panel cutting in a wardrobe configurator.

    5 mistakes that end in a dimension complaint

    • A single “width” field with no description. The customer enters the opening size, production reads it as the product size. The product is too big by two clearances.
    • A single measurement. A measurement at eye level says nothing about the opening size at floor level. Walls out of true only show up during installation.
    • Clearances corrected by hand on every order. Every salesperson subtracts a little differently, and nobody knows who subtracted and who did not. Sometimes the clearance is subtracted twice, sometimes not at all.
    • The same clearance for every material and colour. A long, dark PVC frame moves several times more than a steel one. Too little clearance ends in bowing or a cracked seal.
    • No record of who measured. Without it, every dimension complaint turns into a dispute about whose number it was, and the cost of a new product is usually borne by the manufacturer.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    How does the order dimension differ from the production dimension?

    The order dimension is the number given by the customer or salesperson, most often the size of the opening or recess. The production dimension is the size to which production cuts and assembles the product: after subtracting fitting clearances and allowing for an out-of-true opening, material movement and technological allowances. For a window or fitted furniture the difference is usually from a few to several tens of millimetres.

    How do you measure an opening correctly for a made-to-measure product?

    Measure the width in three places: top, middle and bottom. Measure the height on the left, in the middle and on the right. Production uses the smallest result, and the spread of the measurements shows whether the opening is out of true. It is also worth recording whether the bare masonry or the plastered wall was measured, and whether a sill, floor finish or cladding will still go into the opening.

    How much fitting clearance should you leave for a window?

    It depends on the material, colour and length of the frame and on the system instructions. Window installation guidelines, such as the German RAL guidelines, give minimum gaps that grow with frame length, and dark PVC frames need more room than light ones. In practice the frame is usually ten to twenty millimetres smaller than the opening on each side. The values in the system manufacturer's documentation are binding.

    Who is responsible for a wrong dimension on a made-to-order product?

    Usually whoever measured and gave the dimension, but only if this can be proven. That is why the order should record the dimension type, all measurements, the person who measured and the finished product size approved by the customer. Without this information a dimension dispute often ends with the manufacturer making the product a second time at its own cost. Details of liability depend on the contract, so it is worth agreeing them with a lawyer.

    Can a configurator convert the customer's dimension into the production size by itself?

    Yes. A configurator can ask for several measurements, take the smallest, subtract clearances that depend on product, system and material, check technical limits and store the sales and production dimensions separately on the work order. It can also calculate the cutting list, panel cut parts or sheet metal flat blanks straight away. The process engineer sets the rules, and the salesperson and customer do not need to know them.

    Next step

    If “too small” and “too big” complaints come back every few weeks at your company, send us the order form you use today, a few sample orders and a description of the clearances your production applies. We will show you how to capture these rules in a configurator and quoting system, so that the production size calculates itself, and how much work the first version takes. You will find working configurator examples in JSON Crew showroom.

    Write to us or see what a configurator implementation looks like, from the first conversation to a working MVP.

    Read also

    5 out of 5 (2 votes)
    Next step

    Did you like this article?

    If after reading this you feel your company also has processes worth rebuilding, book a free call. Together we will check where sales are really leaking and what makes sense to implement first.

    Schedule a call
    // Contact

    Schedule a free consultation

    Tell us about your project and we will contact you with a specific plan and quote. No obligations, specific value.

    contact@jsoncrew.com